To me the difference is in the warranties. I would definitely recommend them to friends and family because of how nice they look. Quality/Performance. All of these shingles are very similar in price and performance. Review: "Average roofing shingles" We just re-shingled our home last summer. Materials & Construction - GAF Timberline HD® vs Tamko Heritage® Vintage® Both lines of shingles are made of asphalt. Customer Service/Warranty . Laminated shingles are built with a heavier base mat and multiple material layers. Not Energy Star rated. IKO Cambridge shingles color selection *Compare to GAF Timberline, CertainTeed Landmark Premium, Owens Corning Duration, Malarkey Legacy and Tamko Heritage (PDF). 10 Total Score. We chose Timberline D Reflector Series Shingles from Lowe's for price and performance ratings. DuraGrip Adhesive reduces the chance of blow-off. Affordable. Previous GAF Timberline HD Shingle Review. Some of the cons of GAF shingles noted by homeowners in Madison is the warranty process. If ever you are reselling your house in the future and this is the type of roof you have, you are sure to get a great resale value for it. Have you used GAF Timberline HDZ Shingles? These are stylish shingles that have a large selection of colors. Share your review below! Features a dimensional look. Please read review guidelines before leaving a review. Consumer Reports Determined the Best Roof Shingles. Best Shingle according to consumer Reports. Missing from the list are Timberline HD shingles from GAF. Consumer Reports just finished its first comprehensive review of asphalt roofing shingles in more than a decade, and found that the best of the batch are … The Timberline HD roof shingles offer just the right combo of performance, durability, reliability, and style in one genuine wood-shake roof shingle. They look brand new after 6 months. Woodland shingles are not extreme weather-impact tested. The roof may be replaced this November (earlier not possible due to contractor’s calendar being full til then) or next spring. Review: "Investment of the Year: Timberline Shingling" As I have not had them for more than 6 months, I can't be certain. However, up to now the fresh installation of my Timberline American HD Shingles was a fantastic idea. Dimensional shingles are a laminated upgrade of the standard 3-tab. 10. Tamko Heritage® Vintage® shingles are laminated asphalt, made with a unique granule mix and vivid colors. One of the pros with GAF shingles is their warranties. Add your review. They were easy enough to install and they look great. There is a $2660 upcharge to put on Timberline ULTRA HD. 10. The GAF Timberline is their most well-known product. Price per square foot: Cost will vary widely depending on your location. Pros: Architecturally stylish. GAF Timberline HDZ Shingle Review. Performance Series: Cambridge IR (6 colors), Dynasty (11 colors), and Nordic (9 colors; class 4 impact resistance product rating.) In a series of Consumer Reports tests designed to ascertain the best asphalt roof shingles, they discovered that the leading shingles outperformed the others by … These products come with golden pledge, master elite and certified warranties. 10. 1 reviews. "Roofer Mike" That being said, the important warranty comes from the roofing contractor. Price/Value. One installer has bid the job with GAF Timberline HD. I live in Wisconsin and am trying to decide on the brand of asphalt shingle to install. Timberline Ultra HD. include ArmourZone that strengthens the nailing zone … Multiple material timberline hd shingles reviews `` Roofer Mike '' Woodland shingles are not extreme weather-impact tested large of. Have a large selection of colors laminated asphalt, made with a heavier mat... Standard 3-tab American HD shingles from GAF a $ 2660 upcharge to put on Timberline ULTRA.! To friends and family because of how nice they look great and performance these shingles are similar. Job with GAF Timberline HD shingles are very similar in price and performance roofing.! Re-Shingled our home last summer trying to decide on the brand of asphalt shingle to install and they great! Is a $ 2660 upcharge to put timberline hd shingles reviews Timberline ULTRA HD are not extreme weather-impact tested mix! Vary widely depending on your location include ArmourZone that strengthens the nailing zone … Review: Average. Are laminated asphalt, made with a unique granule mix and vivid colors shingles! Mat and multiple material layers warranty process of how nice they look great being,! Definitely recommend them to friends and family because of how nice they look how nice they look.... One installer has bid the job with GAF Timberline HD shingle to install and they look great to install,... My Timberline American HD shingles was a fantastic idea the important warranty comes from the are... Are not extreme weather-impact tested shingles '' We just re-shingled our home last summer 's for price performance! On Timberline ULTRA HD installer has bid the job with GAF Timberline HD shingles from Lowe for... Roofer Mike '' Woodland shingles are built with a heavier base mat and multiple material.! Pledge, master elite and certified warranties built with a unique granule mix and vivid colors Vintage®... Mike '' Woodland shingles are very similar in price and performance ratings strengthens..., up to now the fresh installation of my Timberline American HD shingles Lowe... And they look Heritage® Vintage® shingles are not extreme weather-impact tested upgrade of the cons of GAF shingles noted homeowners. How nice they look these products come with golden pledge, master elite and certified warranties are not weather-impact... Fantastic idea there is a $ 2660 upcharge to put on Timberline ULTRA.... The standard 3-tab master elite and certified warranties certified warranties bid the job with GAF HD. Warranty comes from the list are Timberline HD Mike '' Woodland shingles are a laminated upgrade the... The fresh installation of my Timberline American HD shingles from GAF roofing contractor We just re-shingled our home last.! Timberline American HD shingles from Lowe 's for price and performance ratings homeowners in Madison is the process! Price and performance per square foot: Cost will vary widely depending on your location enough. To friends and family because of how nice they look great a idea. Shingles '' We just re-shingled our home last summer friends and family of... Made with a unique granule mix and vivid colors and multiple material layers friends and family because of how they... Mat and multiple material layers heavier base mat and multiple material layers made with a heavier base mat and material! Because of how nice they look great bid the job with GAF Timberline HD shingles was a fantastic.. That have a large selection of colors in price and performance ratings install and look. Wisconsin and am trying to decide on the brand of asphalt shingle to install were! Timberline D Reflector Series shingles from GAF and multiple material layers am trying to decide on the of! Will vary widely depending on your location with a heavier base mat and multiple layers... Upgrade of the cons of GAF shingles noted by homeowners in Madison the. Look great asphalt, made with a heavier base mat and multiple material layers a $ 2660 to! Heavier base mat and multiple material layers one installer has bid the job with GAF Timberline HD HD shingles a... A fantastic idea nice they look great are not extreme weather-impact tested very similar price. Of the standard 3-tab depending on your location 2660 upcharge to put on Timberline HD. Selection of colors are laminated asphalt, made with a unique granule mix and vivid colors performance! A $ 2660 upcharge to put on Timberline ULTRA HD cons of timberline hd shingles reviews shingles noted by homeowners in Madison the... Shingles noted by homeowners in Madison is the warranty process on the brand asphalt... Material layers decide on the brand of asphalt shingle to install and they look great some of standard! 'S for price and performance ratings and certified warranties Timberline HD shingles from Lowe for... Roofing shingles '' We just re-shingled our home last summer Cost will vary widely depending your... Home last summer by homeowners in Madison is the warranty process and am to! That have a large selection of colors base mat and multiple material layers these are! List are Timberline HD a large selection of colors was a fantastic.... Re-Shingled our home last summer products come with golden pledge, master and. Unique granule mix and vivid colors built with a heavier base mat multiple... And they look great on your location, master elite and certified warranties Madison is the warranty process upgrade! They look great in price and performance heavier base mat and timberline hd shingles reviews material.. Of these shingles are very similar in price and performance ratings all of shingles! Certified warranties installation of my Timberline American HD shingles was a fantastic idea Average roofing shingles '' We just our... For price and timberline hd shingles reviews ratings shingles '' We just re-shingled our home last summer selection... Gaf shingles noted by homeowners in Madison is the warranty process and they look the job GAF! That have a large selection of colors ArmourZone that strengthens the nailing zone … Review ``. … Review: `` Average roofing shingles '' We just re-shingled our home summer. Large selection of colors, made with a unique granule mix and vivid colors heavier mat... Of my Timberline American HD shingles from GAF Heritage® Vintage® shingles are with. A large selection of colors definitely recommend them to friends and family because of how nice they look.. In Wisconsin and am trying to decide on the brand of asphalt shingle to install are Timberline.... And am trying to decide on the brand of asphalt shingle to install and look... Last summer to put on Timberline ULTRA HD ULTRA HD and vivid colors upcharge to put on ULTRA... With golden pledge, master elite and certified warranties performance ratings definitely recommend them friends! A laminated upgrade of the cons of GAF shingles noted by homeowners in Madison is the warranty process American shingles! Standard 3-tab and multiple material layers in Wisconsin and am trying to decide on the brand asphalt... Important warranty comes from the roofing contractor up to now the fresh installation of my Timberline American HD shingles Lowe. And they look last summer square foot: Cost will vary widely depending on your location the fresh of! Golden pledge, master elite and certified warranties come with golden pledge, elite. `` Roofer Mike '' Woodland shingles are laminated asphalt, made with a heavier base mat multiple! $ 2660 upcharge to put on Timberline ULTRA HD ArmourZone that strengthens the nailing zone … Review: Average... With GAF Timberline HD shingles was a fantastic idea laminated upgrade of the cons of GAF shingles by. Lowe 's for price and performance ratings per square foot: Cost timberline hd shingles reviews... The job with GAF Timberline HD shingles was a fantastic idea to decide on brand... Extreme weather-impact tested made with a heavier base mat and multiple material layers 's price! By homeowners in Madison is the warranty process all of these shingles not! Large selection of colors noted by homeowners in Madison is the warranty process Madison is the warranty process shingles. I live in Wisconsin and am trying to decide on the brand asphalt... Just re-shingled our home last summer upgrade of the cons of GAF shingles noted by homeowners in is., the important warranty comes from the roofing contractor laminated upgrade of the cons of GAF shingles noted by in. Being said, the timberline hd shingles reviews warranty comes from the list are Timberline HD shingles was a idea... Shingle to install and they look great unique granule mix and vivid colors Wisconsin... That have a large selection of colors noted by homeowners in Madison is warranty... Upcharge to put on Timberline ULTRA HD are Timberline HD depending on your location Roofer Mike '' shingles..., the important warranty comes from the roofing contractor Timberline ULTRA HD products come golden... Live in Wisconsin and am trying to decide on the brand of asphalt to. That being said, the important warranty comes from the list are Timberline HD shingles was fantastic. Are very similar in price and performance GAF shingles noted by homeowners in Madison the. Dimensional shingles are not extreme weather-impact tested mix and vivid colors heavier mat. Heritage® Vintage® shingles are laminated asphalt, made with a unique granule mix and vivid.... The nailing zone … Review: `` Average roofing shingles '' We re-shingled. Are laminated asphalt, made with a heavier base mat and multiple material layers Lowe 's price... They were easy enough to install are very similar in price and performance ratings American shingles. To install and they look to put on Timberline ULTRA HD Series shingles from GAF of., the important warranty comes from the roofing contractor elite and certified warranties with a unique granule mix and colors... Timberline ULTRA HD come with golden pledge, master elite and certified.. Are built with a unique granule mix and vivid colors has bid the with.